Four steps to reduce civilian casualties

Today Rick Inderfurth has a piece today arguing that civilian casualties are "rising to the top of the list" of woes in Afghanistan and setting out four steps to reduce them. Let's take a look:

First, the and NATO should publicly adopt the goal of "zero innocent civilian casualties," as recommended a year ago by retired General Barry McCaffrey...to accomplish this, military tactics must change to limit casualties even where this means, in McCaffrey's words, "Taliban units escape destruction by hiding among the people."

So this would essentially be an oath to 'first do no harm'...Such a declaration would be valuable, as long as it was actually observed.

Easier said than done--especially since the current command would tell you they are doing everything possible to avoid civilian deaths. It's clearly not working. McCaffrey, in a June memo (worth reading in its entirety), has some insights into how this approach might be operationalized:

We have to stay out of the cities and push the ANA [Afghan national army] with our backup into civil population control operations. We need to defer on the roads to the civil population while actively countering IED’s and suicide bombers. (Move convoys at night, build by-pass roads, get US military and AID infrastructure out of built-up areas, use ANP [Afghan national police] units to accompany our small unit convoy movements.) Suggest we need to concentrate on the ANA and the ANP…not on large unit US operations.

This requires a shift in how we operate, and a shift in priorities, but one that is not unimaginable. Inderfurth next advocates:

Second, more must be done to put "an Afghan face on operations," as called for by the former NATO commander in Afghanistan, General David Richards of Britain. This means closer coordination on military operations with the Afghan Ministry of Defense and the Afghan National Army. Afghan soldiers should also be included in U.S. and NATO military actions to act as a buffer, a longstanding demand of Karzai. It is also imperative to work more closely with the local authorities and do more to respect Afghan sensibilities. U.S. and NATO policies regarding house searches and detentions of residents should be reconsidered.

This is really two recommendations in one: first a larger role for the Afghan military, and second, a shift in search/detention policies. Both are feasible and desirable, especially as the Afghan Army seems prepared to play a larger role.

Third, the United States should conclude a Status of Forces Agreement with Afghanistan. Such an agreement is intended to clarify the legal terms under which a foreign military is allowed to operate in a country, including locations of bases and access to facilities as well as matters affecting the relations between a military force and civilians. Nearly six years into the U.S. military campaign, a formal, binding understanding with the Afghan government is needed, in part to underscore the political message that the U.S. military is there at the invitation of the Afghan people, not as an "occupier" (which some Afghans are beginning to feel that it is).

Another good recommendation.  The US has proceeded on this issue as if issuing a status of forces agreement would suggest a lack of resolve. It would do precisely the opposite. It would strengthen the credibility of our commitment by laying out, in terms that made sense to our adversaries and our allies, what America's interests and long-term goals in Afghanistan actually are.  (I understand the Pentagon might see benefits to permanent bases in Afghanistan as forward positions to contain Iran and hedge against Russia and China. However, to let these goals drive US Afghanistan policy would be the height of folly, since even if they were valid--and I would question whether they are--they could better achieved in neighboring countries where their pursuit is cheaper and less counterproductive.) We are spending down our goodwill in Afghanistan quickly, and history suggests that once goodwill toward an occupying force is gone, it is gone forever.

Finally, NATO should set up a compensation fund for civilian deaths, injuries or property damage resulting from its military operations in Afghanistan. Since 2002 the United States has appropriated more than $12 million to help Afghan civilians harmed by U.S. operations. The funds are used for medical, rehabilitation and reconstruction aid. But NATO, as a whole, does not have an equivalent program.

Inderfurth implies that the US compensation program is a model, and perhaps it is--I had never seen this figure of $12 million before, which if it's accurate is a remarkable number. Nevertheless, there are some serious problems with the way the US doles out condolence money as well. For one thing, the 19 civilians who were killed by Marines Special Operations forces in March received a mere $2,000 for their loss, while the fifty injured received nothing but an apology. Moreover, as Jon Tracy notes in a May NYT op-ed, there has been a movement to conflate "compensation" payments with "condolence payments" :

Official compensation under the Foreign Claims Act acknowledges wrongdoing; a condolence payment explicitly denies wrongdoing, and the incident is considered, in effect, an accident of war. The Foreign Claims Act offers full compensation for the loss along the lines of what Americans can receive in civil court; condolence involves a nominal payment. But the military has conflated the two, giving condolence payments to the victims' families even as it has investigated and punished wrongdoing by our troops.

So yes, NATO should revisit its policies -- but so should the Pentagon...

Inderfurth's ideas are not new--but they deserve wide circulation at this juncture.

Comments

[angle]

nike ir max

[erehwon]

Take Tiffany, shall love be far behind?

[discount]

air max 1

[discount]

air max 2

[angle]

nike sb dunks

[discount]

airmax

[discount]

nike sb dunks

men mid dunk

[angle]

Paul Smith Wallets

[discount]

men high dunk

nike dunk sb

[angle]

Paul Smith Bags

Paul Smith Belts

[wm]

Several days ago,I bought a pair of Gucci Shoes and some Tiffany jewellery for my mother.She likes Tiffany rings very much.No matther whether it is mothers'day,mother will always love you.and you should love her everyday.Louis Vuitton and Tiffany jewellery are your best choices.we have handbags mall ,and it is a fashion world.From here,you can buy the best lv bags and Tiffany jewellery .You can feel the Latest Fashion .

[wm]

Prada Handbags ,Keen On Sale , Lacoste on sale and MBT On Sale provide you with Louis Vuitton Handbags,Gucci Handbags informaton, Miu Miu Store , New Balance On Sale are for Shoes And Handbags Fashion, Prada On Sale provides Prada Shoes,Gucci Shoes,Louis Vuitton Handbags,Gucci Handbags information, Prada Sell is a blog About gucci shoes,gucci jewelry,gucci handbags and other fashion informatoin, Stuart Weitzman Store , The North Face On Sale

[wm]

Fendi On Sale provide Louis Vuitton Handbags,Fendi Handbags,Gucci Handbags,UGG Shoes informaton, Burberry On Sale provide information about Fashion brand about Gucci,Ugg ,Chanel and Louis Vuitton,
Clarks On Sale ,Converse On Sale tell you about Converse Shoes,UGG Shoes,Gucci Shoes and Handbags Information, Dansko On Sale have Ugg Shoes,Louis Vuitton Handbags ,Gucci Shoes On Sale.

[wm]

Discount Converse is dedicate in Converse Shoes,UGG Shoes,Gucci Shoes ,Louis Vuitton Information, Fossil On Sale has Ugg Shoes,Louis Vuitton Handbags ,Gucci Shoes On Sale, Frye Shop , Frye Store is a Fashion World about most fashionable brands like Louis Vuitton,Gucci,Chanel And UGG Shoes, Heelys Sale have News about Gucci Shoes,UGG Shoes and Louis Vuitton.

[wm]

Cheap Gucci Shoes provide News About Cheap Gucci Shoes and Discount Gucci Men Shoes Replica handbags also provides you news about Replica handbags,Replica Wallets,Replica Shoes,Replica Tiffany,Replica Louis Vuitton, Gucci Shoes is a site About gucci shoes,gucci jewelry,gucci handbags and other gucci fashion informatoin, Discount Handbags Including Louis Vuitton Handbags,Gucci Handbags and Chanel Handbags.

[wm]

Best Designer Handbags Guide you To Buy Designer Handbags, Shoes Design provide Louis Vuitton Handbags ,Gucci Shoes On Sale,Shoes fashion including Gucci Shoes,UGG Shoes and Louis Vuitton Handbags Fashion, Handbags Fashion supply Gucci Handbags and Louis Vuitton Handbags, Footwear collection , Jewelry Trends says Tiffany Jewelry,Louis Vuitton and Gucci Shoes.

[wm]

Fashion World says most fashionable brands like Louis Vuitton,Gucci,Chanel,Gucci Shoes World talks about News about Gucci Shoes,Ugg shoes.Find Ugg information at Ugg Boots News , Chanel Jewelry Shopping for Chanel Jewelry and Gucci Jewelry, Jewelry Brands is the best place to comparison blog for Jewelry Brands.

[wm]

From Uk Tiffany Jewellery ,you can get how to Pick the Tiffany Jewellery, Tiffany World is heading for Tiffany Jewellery Web site Comparing. Sunglasses and Share jewelry

[wm]

Fashion World says Handbags,Shoes and Jewelry fashion style. Find Latest Fashion about Lv,Gucci,Tiffany,Chanel. Tiffany Jewelry is a Tiffany Jewelry & Jewellery Guide Blog, Louis Vuitton online blog for most valueable information, Handbags Mall tells about louis vuitton handbags,Gucci handbags,.etc.

[discount]

men high dunk sb
nike dunk sb shoes

[cheap jordan shoes]

Thank you for your article, the contents of the following which you will like.Cheap Jordan shoes,UGG Boots, Nike SB,Tiffany Rings, Nike Dunk,Tiffany Jewelry for Sale.Who is also a useful information: Nike Dunk SB,Nike SB for Sale ,Gucci Shoes,Christian Louboutin,Bose headphones.

[discount]

dunk sb shoes
mens high dunk

[angle]

Paul Smith Cufflinks

Paul Smith Flip Flop

[discount]

men low dunk

sb dunks

[angle]

Paul Smith Men's Necktie

Paul Smith Notebook