Afghanistan Watch: Sarah Chayes: Don't blame NATO

July 10, 2007

Sarah Chayes: Don't blame NATO

Sarah Chayes writes today in the Times that the US has handed NATO an impossible task and then blamed it for failing to accomplish it. Karzai, she writes, "begged for peacekeepers, spread throughout the country, in those early years," but when NATO invoked Article V it was rebuffed by the administration's reply of "thanks, but no thanks." Her conclusion: Afghanistan is failing because "NATO was brought in too late, and under false pretenses".

Chayes is right about these errors, and has experienced their consequences more directly than most. But she overestimates NATO's capacity and willingness to bear a heavy burden in those early years--and lets it off the hook too easily today (she never mentions, for example, the reality of a two-tier system in which some contributors are willing to fight and others are not.) There is surely more than enough blame to go around for our collective unwillingness, and systematic unreadiness, to provide comprehensive security for Afghanistan.

By suggesting that earlier and broader NATO engagement could have solved Afghanistan's problems, Chayes implies that Afghanistan's troubles call for military solutions. More NATO troops, however, could not have solved a central, structural problem: international efforts have been over militarized, with far too little energy focused on establishing governance and rule of law, among other missing priorities.

NATO Didn't Lose Afghanistan: Kandahar, Afghanistan (NYT op-ed by Sarah Chayes): WHEN things go wrong — touchdown passes are missed, products come out defective, wars are lost — it is typical to blame the equipment, or the help. In the case of the unraveling situation in Afghanistan, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization has become the favorite whipping boy of American officials and military personnel. NATO countries aren’t sending enough troops, we hear. Those who do arrive are constrained by absurd caveats that prevent them from engaging in combat. NATO lost Helmand Province to the Taliban.

In fact, after watching rotation after military rotation cycle through here since late 2001, I see NATO as an improvement over its American predecessors.

Art Credit: Matt Weems

One key difference is NATO’s training program, born of the challenge of gathering troops from different countries, speaking different languages, into a cohesive fighting force. In March, I joined about a dozen civilians who had lived and worked in Kandahar for years at the final training exercise for the NATO officers who recently took over Afghanistan’s Regional Command South. We spent 10 days briefing them, fielding their questions on everything from tribal relations to the electricity supply, eating meals with them and playing roles in a simulation of three days in southern Afghanistan.

“Uh ... we’ve got a bit of a situation here,” I heard one of my fellow teachers, an Australian who was a top United Nations security official, say calmly into the phone. He threw me a wink. He was starting the simulation by reporting the sounds of a large detonation and small arms fire. Later, on another line to an officer training to run public information, a sociological researcher played the role of a journalist, her voice incredulous: “Are you sure you want to say that?”

With the help of these seasoned civilians, experienced NATO officers and some Afghans, the new team was rigorously tested on the many aspects of its mission that go beyond combat tactics. Three months later, after these trainees had taken up their new jobs, the training staff traveled to Kandahar to debrief them to learn which aspects of the training had been useful and which needed improvement.

Given the constant disruption caused by short troop rotations, competent training is key to improving officers’ effectiveness as soon as they hit the ground.

The American troops’ training, in contrast, seemed ad hoc, usually carried out by each unit on its own, rather than by a dedicated training staff. And it involved very few civilians, despite the crucial humanitarian and political aspects of the mission here. (I have occasionally been invited to address American officers, but only when a friend in the unit has convinced a commander that I might have something to offer.)

NATO’s second advantage is continuity, despite its multinational makeup. I observed rivalry between American units lead to confusing policy reversals each time new troops came in. The best American commanders were those who understood that Afghanistan is no toy-soldier battlefield, that they would have to bone up on anthropology, diplomacy and civil engineering. But such commanders were rare, and their replacements — seeking to make their own mark — usually undid their work within weeks.

NATO has tried to reduce the disruption of replacing troops and officers en masse. Rotations are staggered. This may cause some logistical headaches, but it reduces abrupt changes in direction.

But if NATO is doing better than the United States, why is Afghanistan doing worse? The answer is twofold. NATO was brought in too late, and under false pretenses.

Within days after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, NATO voted to invoke Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty — its core principle, which states that an armed attack on one member will be viewed by the others as an attack on themselves. Never before in the history of the organization had the principle been activated. The American reaction was thanks but no thanks. Our government was sure we could go it alone in Afghanistan, that allies would be an inconvenience.

In 2003, NATO moved peacekeeping forces into Kabul and parts of northern Afghanistan. But not until 2005, when it was clear that the United States was bogged down in Iraq and lacked sufficient resources to fight on two fronts, did Washington belatedly turn to NATO to take the Afghan south off its hands. And then it misrepresented the situation our allies would find there. NATO was basically sold a beefed-up peacekeeping mission. It was told, in effect, that it would simply need to maintain the order the United States had established and to help with reconstruction and security.

In fact, as was clear from the ground, the situation had been deteriorating since late 2002. By 2004, resurgent Taliban were making a concerted push to enter the country from Pakistan, and intensive combat between American forces and Taliban fighters was taking place north of Kandahar. By 2005, top Afghan officials could be blown up in downtown Kandahar without drawing much of a reaction from either the Afghan government or ours. Notorious drug lords governed the three main southern provinces to which we were dispatching our allies. It was the bloodiest and most belligerent situation since the fall of the Taliban.

NATO should have been brought in from the start and given the kind of muscular peacekeeping mission it learned to conduct in the Balkans. Afghanistan’s president, Hamid Karzai, begged for peacekeepers, spread throughout the country, in those early years when they could still have made a difference.

Having snubbed our allies when we should have accepted their help, and having stuck them with the most difficult, yet most strategically critical, part of Afghanistan, the least we could do now is offer gratitude and support, rather than blame our friends for our own follies.
Sarah Chayes is the author of “The Punishment of Virtue: Inside Afghanistan After the Taliban.”

Posted by Carl Robichaud on July 10, 2007 at 03:32 PM in Europe, ISAF / NATO, Politics, Security, Taliban, U.S. Policy | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341d843653ef00e550a56d198834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Sarah Chayes: Don't blame NATO:

The comments to this entry are closed.

Comments

It is the silkroad gold which make me very happy these days,
my brother says sro gold is his favorite games gold he likes,
he usually buy some silkroad online gold to start his game
most of the time he will win the silk road gold back and give me some cheap silkroad gold to play the game.

Posted by: cheap silkroad gold | January 19, 2009 at 10:18 PM

Yesterday, my boyfriend gave me a lot of Asda Story money and I buy Asda Story Gold as the gift to return him.

The Asda Story gold is attractive and I have plenty of the cheap Asda Story gold.

Posted by: Asda Story gold | February 24, 2009 at 01:47 AM

Do you know Rose zuly? I like it.
My brother often go to the internet bar to buy rose zulie and play it.
After school, He likes playing games using these rose online zuly with his friend.
I do not like to play it. Because I think that it not only costs much money but also spend much time. One day, he give me many rose online zulieand play the game with me.
I came to the bar following him and found Arua ROSE zulywas so cheap. After that, I also go to play game with him.

Posted by: Rose zuly | March 14, 2009 at 05:52 AM

Today, you can walk into Laptop parts many brick-and-mortar Laptop Acer AC Adapter electronics and computers retailers Gateway Laptop keyboard and expect to find laptop bargains. Toshiba Laptop keyboard They are just about everywhere. Dell Laptop AC Adapter Prices for bargain laptops have become so low that walking out of a store with one for yourself and Liteon Laptop AC Adapter and one for a friend is even an option. Laptop LCD AC Adapter To save the most money Acer Aspire 1200 AC Adapter when buying a bargain laptop Liteon PA-1131-08 AC Adapter or notebook Gateway PA-1650-01 AC Adapter
Liteon PA-1650-01 AC Adapter
Toshiba Laptop AC Adapter
Toshiba PA3467U-1ACA AC Adapter
Original Gateway PA-1650-01 AC Adapter
Toshiba PA3469U-1ACA AC Adapter
Acer PA-1650-02 AC Adaptercomputer, though, Delta PA-1650-02 AC Adapter going through a major online retailer Liteon PA-1131-08 AC Adapter is the best way to save the most money. Dell Laptop battery that is very important.

Posted by: lynn | April 26, 2009 at 02:08 AM

Is anyone hunting the ways to get enough EverQuest II Platinum to increase their fun in the game? I am, so I hope someone can give me some advice on how to make EverQuest II Platinum free. At the same time, if you know more about EverQuest II Power Leveling, it is ok, and it would be better if you can provide me with some useful EverQuest II Power Leveling guides. Out of runes of magic gold? Need it in urgent? Yes, I can understand you. As the most important currency, without rom gold, you ever can’t do anything. Crazy about running warhammer gold? Yup, it is so crucial indeed for us in Warhammer Online. Without it, we can even do nothing, without money to buy items, weapons and so on. So enough warhammer gold is substantial. Then is warhammer power leveling essential, too? Yes, you are right, you can level your char faster by warhammer power leveling service. And you should buy enough aoc gold in Age of Conan, because aoc gold is the important currency which would help you to enjoy your game life better. The latest aion power leveling can be found at Gmbar now! GMBar.com is skilled level team for years and can help you to buy aion power leveling fast and safe! As the currency in the Final Fantasy XI, enough FFXI Gil is very important. Compared with other FFXI service offering stores, Gamevive.com have lots of cheap Final Fantasy XI Gil in stock, so come here to get your cheapest Final Fantasy XI Gil now. Ok, we have lots of EVE ISK mining guide. Good luck and enjoy collecting your EVE Online ISK. Stop looking around for atlantica gold (atlantica online gold) now. Get the gold from GMbar is a short cut to enjoy more fun in the game! Just buy cheap atlantica gold with fast delivery here!

Posted by: wow gold | June 11, 2009 at 05:58 AM

Posted by: wow gold | June 11, 2009 at 05:59 AM

buy wow gold
cheap wow power leveling
my wow gold
cheapest wow power leveling
BUY wow gold
cheap wow power leveling
CHEAP rs gold
good wow power leveling
MY lotro gold
CHEAPEST aion gold
buy wow gold
cheap wow gold
CHEAPEST wow gold

Posted by: wow gold | July 07, 2009 at 10:33 PM

Thank you very much for this information.
Good post thanks for sharing.
I like this site ;)
-----------

ihale ihale, ihaleler
Dizi izle Dizi izleme sitesi
premium Wordpress themes premium Wordpress themes sites
TONER TONER bilgileri sitesi
iyi siteler iyi siteler listesi
film izle film izle sitesi
chat chat sitesi
nokia indir nokia indirme sitesi
dantel dantel sayfası
sex shop sex shop sitesi
yemek tarifleri yemek tarifleri web sayfası
müzik dinle müzik dinleme sitesi